The Real McCoy 5 Years

Classic vanilla-oak mixer with good value

Vanilla and caramel
Good for cocktails
Good value
RumX community voice

Approachable Barbados rum with vanilla, caramel and oak, light body and short finish. Reviewers recommend it mainly for mixing and value, though some note thinness and a slight alcohol bite.

34.90 €

Already purchased 110 times

Why shop with RumX?
As seen in:
Most popular rum app:
RumX Team

Details about this rum

Country
Distillery
Brand
The Real McCoy
RumX ID
RX891
ABV
40%
Category
Pot & Column Still Rum
Made from
Molasses
Distillation
Pot and Column Still
Age
5 years
Bottle volume
70cl
Foursquare 5yr   40% The Real McCoy 5 Years

Live auctions

This rum is currently being offered by one of our verified auction house partners. RumX helps you discover and bid on rare rums.

    How does this rum taste?

    RumX members praise this Foursquare-made 5-year for its approachable, classic Barbados profile—vanilla, caramel and oak with touches of dried fruit and cocoa. Often enjoyed in cocktails, it’s light on the palate and considered good value, a popular pick with 50 reviews and strong buyer confidence. Some find it thin or a bit sharp at 40%, but many see it as a reliable mixer that sips decently.

    Aroma

    Vanilla Oak Caramel Hazelnut

    Taste

    Oak Caramel Praline Cocoa

    How is this rum rated?

    Rating (0-10)
    7.1/10 53 reviews

    Stipkavejsie, interesting, longer, distinctly nuts and almonds, probably the longest stiplavost but we'll see, the second degu...aroma of almond butter and fine spirity, oak, in the taste simpler, subtle sweetness, but also still at 5 years old quite pungent, but I'm raising to 7.8m from 7.6

    A solid rum, good for cocktails ok for sipping. The nose gives off caramel, vanilla, and oak notes with a little banana. The rum is light on the tongue with caramel and vanilla as the primary taste. The finish is slightly better than the palate with vanilla, dried fruit, and barrel spices.

    01.05.2019 Nice tasting with friends including my slow cooked pot roast. Colour Medium dark in colour. Nose Light, light wood, faint roasted, dried fruit, caramel, light floral, spice. Palate Light, sweet, light wood, dried fruit, light floral, faint pineapple, spice, light chocolate, light caramel. Finish Short to medium, light wood, sweet, light dried fruit, faint citrus, light chocolate, faint caramel. Extra note. Surprisingly good at the age and price tag.

    A good rum for mixing to provide a pretty classic baking spices and sweets note. If I’m reaching something in this style to sip, I’m going all the way to Foursquare ECA. This lacks to complexity of dark tobacco notes and highlights, like orange zest, that elevate Foursquare’s premium product. Still very nice and great value.

    Rate

    Expert reviews

    Are you a blogger and want to publish your articles for free on RumX to boost your reach? Contact us!

    Community purchases

    The RumX community has already added 110 bottles to their collections:

    closed
    66
    opened
    24
    emptied
    20
    Open rate
    40%

    Digitize your rum collection and get exciting insights into the market value of your collection or individual bottles:

    You may also enjoy

    The identification of similar rums is based on the tasting notes of the community and the key data of the rum.

    RX310
    Bottle of The Real McCoy 12 Years

    The Real McCoy 12 Years

    12yr   40%

    - (0)
    60 €
    RX296
    Bottle of The Real McCoy Limited Edition Rum (Madeira Cask)

    The Real McCoy Limited Edition Rum (Madeira Cask)

    12yr   46%

    - (0)
    110 €
    RX209
    Bottle of Finest Barbados Rum

    Finest Barbados Rum

    10yr   43%

    - (0)
    59 €
    RX10196
    Bottle of Rare Casks 12 Years

    Rare Casks 12 Years

    12yr   43%

    - (0)
    43 €
    RX2691
    Bottle of Probitas

    Probitas

    47%

    - (0)
    38 €
    RX5701
    Bottle of White Overproof

    White Overproof

    Unaged   63%

    - (0)
    33 €
    RX775
    Bottle of Spiced Rum

    Spiced Rum

    2yr   37,5%

    - (0)
    27 €
    RX323
    Bottle of Plantation O.F.T.D. Overproof

    Plantation O.F.T.D. Overproof

    14yr   69%

    - (0)
    23 €
    RX1002
    Bottle of Doorly’s 5 Years

    Doorly’s 5 Years

    5yr   40%

    - (0)
    26 €
    RX66
    Bottle of Black Tot Rum

    Black Tot Rum

    5yr   46,2%

    - (0)
    40 €
    RX165
    Bottle of Single Estate Reserve

    Single Estate Reserve

    10yr   45%

    - (0)
    60 €
    RX6875
    Bottle of Reserve

    Reserve

    8yr   43%

    - (0)
    36 €
    RX501
    Bottle of The Real McCoy Limited Edition Rum (Virgin Oak)

    The Real McCoy Limited Edition Rum (Virgin Oak)

    2017   10yr   46%

    - (0)
    65 €
    RX330
    Bottle of 5 Stars 8 Years Réserve Spéciale

    5 Stars 8 Years Réserve Spéciale

    8yr   43%

    - (0)
    31 €
    RX9767
    Bottle of 109 Jamaica Rum

    109 Jamaica Rum

    3yr   54,5%

    - (0)
    32 €
    RX714
    Bottle of El Dorado 8

    El Dorado 8

    8yr   40%

    - (0)
    26 €
    RX5390
    Bottle of Rum Fire

    Rum Fire

    63%

    - (0)
    27 €
    RX134
    Bottle of Plantation XAYMACA Special Dry

    Plantation XAYMACA Special Dry

    1yr - 3yr   43%

    - (0)
    26 €
    RX1318
    Bottle of Rum-Bar White Overproof

    Rum-Bar White Overproof

    63%

    - (0)
    23 €
    RX4245
    Bottle of The Real McCoy 12 Years

    The Real McCoy 12 Years

    12yr   46%

    - (0)
    RX2046
    Bottle of Rum-Bar Gold

    Rum-Bar Gold

    4yr   40%

    - (0)
    20 €
    RX16
    Bottle of Rare Blend 12 Years

    Rare Blend 12 Years

    12yr   43%

    - (0)
    58 €
    RX168
    Bottle of 2006

    2006

    2006   10yr   62%

    - (0)
    1,131 €
    RX1410
    Bottle of The Real McCoy 3 Years

    The Real McCoy 3 Years

    3yr   40%

    - (0)
    30 €
    RX40
    Bottle of Exceptional Cask Selection III

    Exceptional Cask Selection III

    2004   11yr   59%

    - (0)
    454 €
    RX98
    Bottle of Chairman’s Reserve The Forgotten Casks

    Chairman’s Reserve The Forgotten Casks

    11yr   40%

    - (0)
    37 €
    RX16399
    Bottle of Exceptional Cask Selection XXIII Covenant

    Exceptional Cask Selection XXIII Covenant

    2005   18yr   58%

    - (0)
    176 €
    RX17298
    Bottle of The Nectar Of The Daily Drams Barbados

    The Nectar Of The Daily Drams Barbados

    2013   10yr   64,9%

    - (0)
    127 €
    RX106
    Bottle of Gunpowder Proof (Black Label)

    Gunpowder Proof (Black Label)

    3yr   54,5%

    - (0)
    30 €
    RX424
    Bottle of Private Cask Selection Hereditas (The Whisky Exchange)

    Private Cask Selection Hereditas (The Whisky Exchange)

    14yr   56%

    - (0)
    189 €
    RX16127
    Bottle of Rum Sponge NAS 15 (2005 & 2007)

    Rum Sponge NAS 15 (2005 & 2007)

    15yr   50%

    - (0)
    175 €
    RX21
    Bottle of El Dorado 12

    El Dorado 12

    12yr   40%

    - (0)
    41 €
    RX63
    Bottle of Exceptional Cask Selection VII Dominus

    Exceptional Cask Selection VII Dominus

    2008   10yr   56%

    - (0)
    403 €
    RX12829
    Bottle of Barbados No. 15

    Barbados No. 15

    2006   15yr   61,5%

    - (0)
    136 €
    RX43
    Bottle of Smith & Cross Traditional Jamaican Rum

    Smith & Cross Traditional Jamaican Rum

    3yr   57%

    - (0)
    25 €
    RX7604
    Bottle of Chairman‘s Reserve Legacy

    Chairman‘s Reserve Legacy

    43%

    - (0)
    29 €
    RX313
    Bottle of Doorly‘s 14 Years

    Doorly‘s 14 Years

    14yr   48%

    - (0)
    63 €
    RX10082
    Bottle of Exceptional Cask Selection XVII

    Exceptional Cask Selection XVII

    2009   12yr   60%

    - (0)
    128 €
    RX2278
    Bottle of English Harbour 5 Years

    English Harbour 5 Years

    5yr   40%

    - (0)
    21 €
    RX12150
    Bottle of Elliott Erwitt (Magnum)

    Elliott Erwitt (Magnum)

    2005   61%

    - (0)
    482 €
    RX8515
    Bottle of Doorly‘s 12 Years

    Doorly‘s 12 Years

    12yr   43%

    - (0)
    50 €
    RX770
    Bottle of Finest Barbados Rum Export Proof

    Finest Barbados Rum Export Proof

    10yr   46%

    - (0)
    48 €
    RX116
    Bottle of Plantation 3 Stars White

    Plantation 3 Stars White

    10yr   41,2%

    - (0)
    19 €
    RX12828
    Bottle of Barbados No. 14

    Barbados No. 14

    1999   22yr   61%

    - (0)
    199 €
    RX14449
    Bottle of Floral Rum Series Dwarf Poinciana (Catawiki)

    Floral Rum Series Dwarf Poinciana (Catawiki)

    2006   15yr   60,4%

    - (0)
    257 €
    RX212
    Bottle of Doorly‘s 12 Years

    Doorly‘s 12 Years

    12yr   40%

    - (0)
    56 €
    RX175
    Bottle of Doorly’s XO Sherry Finish

    Doorly’s XO Sherry Finish

    12yr   40%

    - (0)
    32 €
    RX133
    Bottle of Plantation Barbados 5 Years

    Plantation Barbados 5 Years

    5yr   40%

    - (0)
    22 €
    RX744
    Bottle of Original Admiralty (Blue Label)

    Original Admiralty (Blue Label)

    40%

    - (0)
    20 €
    RX647
    Bottle of Chairman‘s Reserve Original

    Chairman‘s Reserve Original

    5yr   40%

    - (0)
    21 €

    Want to discover more rums?

    Download the free RumX app:

    About the Foursquare distillery

    The Foursquare distillery is located in Barbados. Rums from Foursquare have been reviewed 11,667 times with an average of 8.3/10.

    Rums: 570
    Avg Rating: 8.3/10
    RumX Team Photo

    By rum lovers, for rum lovers

    I'm Oliver – together with Jakob, Robert, and Lukas, we started RumX in 2018 as a small passion project in Stuttgart, back then under the name Rum Tasting Notes.

    What began as a digital tasting diary is now the world's most comprehensive platform for rum fans: over 24,000 bottlings, 260,000+ independent reviews, and an active community with 47,000 members. We combine the collective intelligence of our community with an integrated marketplace, allowing you to shop securely and manage your collection directly from the app.

    The goal? To offer you, the rum connoisseur, a place where you can choose with confidence—without paperwork, detours, or expert jargon.

    Learn more about us

    Get the most out of RumX

    Do you want to learn more about this rum, track the market value of your bottles, and share your rum with like-minded people? Download the RumX app for free now and discover the whole RumX universe!

    Download app on App Store Download app on Google Play