Mystique Private Cask (The Whisky Exchange)
Foursquare fans and bourbon/whisky drinkers who enjoy dry, oak‑driven cask strength spirits with sherry influence, a touch of bitterness and zero added sugar.
Details about this rum
Live auctions
This rum is currently being offered by one of our verified auction house partners. RumX helps you discover and bid on rare rums.
How does this rum taste?
Most love its powerful yet balanced Foursquare profile, vivid sherry fruit and great integration for 62%. Critics mention strong tannins, slight bitterness and price. Consensus: a top‑tier, characterful Foursquare.
If you already enjoy Foursquare ECS or bourbon cask strengths, this pushes things further with more sherry, oak and tannins—rewarding if you like dry intensity over easy sweetness.
Beginners, those sensitive to high ABV, or drinkers preferring soft, sweet rums without tannins, wood bitterness or premium pricing.
Expert reviews
Are you a blogger and want to publish your articles for free on RumX to boost your reach? Contact us!
Community purchases
The RumX community has already added 54 bottles to their collections:
Digitize your rum collection and get exciting insights into the market value of your collection or individual bottles:
You may also enjoy
The identification of similar rums is based on the tasting notes of the community and the key data of the rum.
About the Foursquare distillery
The Foursquare distillery is located in Barbados. Rums from Foursquare have been reviewed 12,038 times with an average of 8.3/10.
By rum lovers, for rum lovers
I'm Oliver – together with Jakob, Robert, and Lukas, we started RumX in 2018 as a small passion project in Stuttgart, back then under the name Rum Tasting Notes.
What began as a digital tasting diary is now the world's most comprehensive platform for rum fans: over 24,000 bottlings, 270,000+ independent reviews, and an active community with 50,000 members. We combine the collective intelligence of our community with an integrated marketplace, allowing you to shop securely and manage your collection directly from the app.
The goal? To offer you, the rum connoisseur, a place where you can choose with confidence—without paperwork, detours, or expert jargon.













nah this rum is crazy . it’s worth the money . the nose is so brilliantly balanced between a wonderful treacle/caramel component with a healthy dose of blackberry starburst and stewed apples , all backed by a soft edge of coconut and slight hint of oak. The palate is spice galore at first, it starts gingery and slightly cinnamony , then proceeds into a dreamy combination of toffee and tobacco box reminiscent flavors. All of this is so beautifully combined with a pineapple/blackberry fruitiness that lingers longingly on the finish and a slight bit of spice and oak that surfaces but does not overpower the finish. Incredible and might ruin my bank account. This is a life changing rum for me.
Die Nase wittert sofort die Foursquare-Herkunft. Könnte auch ein Doorlys 14y sein. Im Geschmack dann schön tief und komplex. Toffee, Haselnuss-Röstaromen, Vanille, Karamell. Alkohol wirklich gut eingebunden. Schöner langer Abgang. Die Vanille entlässt einen sanft in den Abend.Toller Rum!
#4594 29.01.2024 Relaxing at home with this nice sample I received today. A rather intensive rum wich settles a bit with a few drops of water. This is a pretty different profile with a lot of punch. I like it a lot but I think this one will split the waters a bit. Rest for a long time or add a few drops of water. The tannins are close to taking the first row here ☺️ Nose Intense, balanced, wood, light roasted, berries, faint mint, light caramel, light sherry notes. Palate Lightly oily, balanced, complex, wood, medium roasted, tannins, fruity, light mint, faint caramel. Finish Warm, wood, light roasted, tannins, dried fruit. The empty glass has some light chocolate and light camphor notes. Will see if I can get my hands on a bottle.
A very good Foursquare. Very drinkable despite its high ABV. Basically normal FS markers. The finish has more fruity, peachy notes which I like. Even slightly dirty flavors are there. Only the finish seems a little flat.