Old Jamaican Rum (Aficionados) NYE

The following 94 New Yarmouths were in the blind tasting glass The preliminary result 1ST RX10164 2. RX12050 3. RX12183 4. RX10531 5. RX16026 6. RX10419 7. RX13113 8. RX10167 9. RX15643 10. RX10204 11. RX12556 12. RX12841 13. RX9617 14. RX1563 15. RX16027 16. RX12161 17. RX13824 18. RX6983 In my blind tasting of 5 different NY '94s, this one was in 1st place. A detailed report will follow in the individual tasting.

Rather a little on the woody/roasty side. Beautifully intense and a great long finish. Edit: I've now had it in my glass several times and tasted it against other NY94 contenders and I have to say that for me it's right up there. It's hard to believe that it's still available and at an incredibly fair price. I also really like the size of the bottle (350ml).

Great NY94, love the profile. More fruity & less complex than its brother, but still on a high level. Could bath in these old Jamaicans! //update: yummz! Love the fruityness paired with the intense tropical aging.

The second Fine Dram for today. At 68%, but more is not possible. Again such an old grenade. Tropically matured for 24 years. Madness. Nose: oha, the high ABV first bites properly. It takes a bit until the aromas open up behind it. But then I have wonderful tropical fruit, tart sweet passion fruit and passion fruit, and some tart gooseberry and tangerine. After the fruit, esters and vinegar find their way in ever so slightly, framed by vanilla and cream toffee. With a little patience and care, a beautiful, dense and full-bodied nose. 8.9 Palate: very powerful and intense. Decently astringent and slightly bitter at the start. Roasty and spicy with nutmeg and pepper. At the same time, fruity with lemon zest, grapefruit and distinct coconut. The 68% is quite demanding on the palate. Fruit and spice are already in balance. The finish adds a pleasant note of violets. I like the flavor curve. 8.9 Overall a bit too brute, but with patience it stretches you deep. The long tropical aging makes this NY nicely compact and intense.

Oak, fruits, vanille

Typical New Yarmouth 1994 profile, but with a little more spiciness. Is not quite enough in my eyes for the top tier of NY94 releases, but a great rum remains this release anyway.

Tasted against the sister bottling at 68.5 eser has the rounder and less pungent nose. The other is possibly Somewhat more diverse. Slightly different but on points for me about the same. Both very good but both no exception 94s NY - but in any case a very good PLV.

A rather sharp and narrow nose, but notes of caramel and fruit (prune) soften the harshness. The palate attacks with prune, resin and bark. The finish is long and bitter. A fine rum, but the direct comparison with its 68.5% brother is clearly to its disadvantage.

A little cross-tasting with the two Fine Drams and the FRC Village. All three initially need a lot of time in the glass before they open up. All three are very good 94s NY, but do not reach the top. For me, the benchmark here remains the RA! The Fine Dram with 68.5% is the winner here. Despite the high alcohol content, it is very pleasantly creamy. The nose is quite restrained, but it shows its potential on the palate, where it dominates (even if the cask is clearly noticeable). For me, the most harmonious NY this evening. The FRC follows second. The sweetness of the Sheery finish is clearly perceptible, but it's still just right. The third is the Fine Dram at 68%. It is very brute and not quite as balanced. In summary, these are all very good bottlings

Beautiful, powerful New Yarmouth. Who likes a lot of power is right here. Good PLV.

Arrived today, immediately opened, so it must. 😉 Preliminary: Do not be deterred by the sealing, which is very opening-friendly.After the unproblematic opening of the handy bottle (my new favorite size 😍) I wanted to shout "Hallelujah!", so a great fragrance flowed towards me. I thought I was already in paradise, which is probably only a tropically matured rum (here considerable 25 of a total of more than 28 and not only 26 years, label is outdated according to the bottler).On the palate I perceived at first mainly wood - but then came the alcohol with force! But that is neither surprising nor unpleasant at 68%, the alcohol content extends the finish to infinity. So this is a true finish rum - and at NY I'm into it. This also nicely conceals the fact that the rum lacks fruitiness and depth somewhat for my sensibilities. But let's be honest: Do you really want to expect elegant finesse from a stunner rum? Even if this brand new rum can't play in the top league of the '94 NYs because of the minor flaws, it certainly met my expectations.Whether its brother is on par with 68.5% remains to be seen. (Both rums are surprisingly still available.) Cheers!

Beautiful 1994 NY ... for me, the limit is almost reached here...longer in the barrel would be suboptimal. Alcohol despite the yet high age very present.

Wieder mal ein guter 1994er NY Vintage. Insgesamt mir persönlich etwas zu wenig Komplexität und zu viel Röstaromen. Der Alkohol ist auch Recht präsent und wenig eingebunden. Aromatisch hauptsächlich dunkle Schokolade, Kokoschips und dunkles, leicht gesalzenes Karamell mit recht viel getoastetem Holz. Definitiv noch Luft nach oben.

Nose: red fruits in glue. Taste: liquid children's eucalyptus. Again the red fruits. Finish of medium length. The alcohol is unfortunately not well integrated, it can not deny its 68%.